‘Breadwinner’ Rotten Tomatoes Reviews Say Bargatze Brings Home Stale Comedy

"The Breadwinner" key art featuring Nate Bargatze.

Sony Pictures Entertainment

The Breadwinner, a family comedy starring stand-up comedian Nate Bargatze in his feature film debut, is being met with some not-so-fresh-reviews from Rotten Tomatoes critics.

Written by Bargatze and directed by Eric Appel (Die Hart, Weird: The Al Yankovic Story), The Breadwinner plays in preview screenings on Thursday before opening in theaters nationwide on Friday.

Forbes‘Backrooms’ Projected To Beat ‘Mandalorian And Grogu’ In Debut At Weekend Box OfficeBy Tim Lammers

Bargatze stars as Nate Wilcox, a successful salesman who stumbles into a chaotic life as a stay-at-home dad to three daughters after his wife, Katie (Mandy Moore), lands a life-changing deal on Shark Tank to put her household invention into play.

Rated PG, The Breadwinner also stars Colin Jost, Zach Cherry, Martin Herlihy, Kate Berlant, Kumail Nanjiani and Will Forte.

As of Thursday, The Breadwinner has earned a 40% “rotten” critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes’ Tomatometer based on 10 reviews. The Breadwinner’s Critics Consensus, Audience Summary and Popcornmeter score are also still pending.

Forbes‘Obsession’ Star Inde Navarrette Pinpoints Where We’ll See Nikki NextBy Tim Lammers

Note: This article will be updated when more reviews are posted.

What Are Individual Critics Saying About ‘The Breadwinner’?

William Bibbiani of The Wrap is among the top critics on RT who gives the film a “rotten” score, writing that “The Breadwinner has more stale corny bits than a Kellogg’s factory dumpster.”

Natalia Winkelman of Variety also gives The Breadwinner a “rotten” score. Winkelman writes in her RT review summary, “Select moments may land a laugh, but zoom out a little, and the real joke is that this movie was made in 2026.”

Frank Scheck of The Hollywood Reporter also slams the film, writing in his “rotten” RT review summary, “The Breadwinner is so lazy and laid-back that it practically recedes into itself. This is a film that makes television shows like Father Knows Best and My Three Sons seem edgy.”

The Breadwinner doesn’t find any mercy from AV Club’s Matt Schimkowitz, either. Schimkowitz writes in his “rotten” RT review summary, “Bargatze’s commitment to ‘clean’ comedy, which is to say, material that is inoffensive to white upper-class suburbanites, means defanging whatever bite Breadwinner might otherwise have.”

Glenn Kenny of The New York Times is among the top critics who gives The Breadwinner a “fresh” score on RT. Kenny writes in his RT review summary, “Bargatze proves himself a savvy writer and performer here; he doesn’t hog all the laugh lines for himself, but instead often plays straight man to his three daughters... It’s the girls who ultimately make this comedy sing.”

Alison Foreman of IndieWire also awards the the film a “fresh” score on RT, writing, “For the most part, Appel wisely avoids pushing Nate toward overly heightened emotional territory — instead, treating Bargatze’s deadpan confusion like its own immutable law of physics inside the silly world of The Breadwinner.”

The Breadwinner plays in Thursday previews before opening in theaters nationwide on Friday.