Conflict Resolution For Leaders: How To “Fight Right”

Conflict resolution is a useful skill for anyone, but leaders in particular can benefit from learning how to “fight right.”

getty

Avoiding a difficult conversation may feel easier in the short run, but in the long run, it’s bound to lead to greater friction and misunderstandings. While skipping the tough talk may feel like a safe choice because it keeps the peace—at least temporarily—the truth is that it allows issues to continue mounting beneath the seemingly calm surface. Conflict resolution is a useful skill for anyone, but leaders in particular can benefit from learning how to “fight right.”

The Problem with Avoiding Conflict

In my leadership trainings, I use an exercise called the Great Orange Debate. Two groups—one representing doctors, the other representing medical researchers—are each fighting over the same oranges. What they don’t realize at first is that neither one needs the whole orange. The doctors need only the rind to cure their patients, while the researchers need only the juice to further their science. Nobody has to lose. But if they don’t take the time to communicate and understand each side’s needs, they won’t figure that out and risk walking away empty-handed. Most conflicts aren’t zero-sum—but it requires engagement, not avoidance, to realize that.

Techniques for Conflict Resolution

Creating neutral ground from the beginning helps keep people from entering the conversation with their defenses up. Starting the discussion with something like, “Let’s talk about something that’s important to both of us” is more effective than jumping into accusations or demands. Letting the other party speak first is a gesture of goodwill that can also help neutralize things.

Throughout the conversation, embrace the power of questions over statements. When you make a statement, it can feel like an attack, and the defenses go up—whereas when you ask a question, the defenses come down. It’s also helpful to look for common ground. The key is to listen to understand, not just to respond. Sometimes you discover that you’re actually saying the same things, just using different words.

In any conflict, there are always factors beneath the surface that you cannot see—a health crisis, financial stress, family troubles. Approaching conflicts with the awareness that there’s always more to the story than meets the eye can transform how you respond. Imagine the other person in a body of dark water; you can only see what’s above the surface, so they may look fine. But you have no idea what’s happening beneath it.

Maintaining psychological safety is a priority in any conflict resolution process. When people feel psychologically safe, they’re more likely to share their real thoughts rather than withdrawing or becoming defensive. The power of the pause can be immensely helpful toward creating that sense of safety on both sides. The key is to respond, not react. If you pause and let that emotion calm down, you can respond from a place of logic rather than pure feeling.

Finally, at the end of any discussion, I always like to follow up in writing, which creates clarity and prevents misunderstandings later. So, coming back to The Great Orange Debate, the conversation might end with a simple written agreement: The medical team will receive the orange rinds for patient treatment, and the research team will receive the juice for their studies. Both groups will coordinate on sourcing to ensure an adequate supply for each.

Conflict Resolution Requires Courage

Avoidance doesn’t solve problems. If anything, it risks making them worse. Avoidance also results in inauthenticity. When you keep saying yes and staying agreeable to keep the peace, you’re being inauthentic to yourself. It might be better for everyone else if you’re honest instead of trying to make everybody happy—and it’s definitely better for your own peace.

Conflict resolution is a learnable skill that improves with practice and self-awareness—and one that forms the cornerstone of meaningful relationships, personal and professional alike. It takes time to master and courage to practice, but it’s well worth the effort.