Giants forced to face harsh reality with Luis Arraez amid trade, extension rumors

1 hour ago 2

The San Francisco Giants are sitting near the bottom of Major League Baseball's standings this season, and are very likely to be trade deadline sellers.

At this point, it's been widely reported that Luis Arraez is likely to be traded at the deadline. It makes sense, as he's signed to a one-year, $!2 million deal. If he were under contract for longer, the breakout All-Star would be worth keeping.

But, as USA Today's Bob Nightengale highlighted, the Giants are forced to face the harsh reality when it comes to Arraez this year amid trade rumors and the potential for an extension. Arraez, unfortunately, probably has to be traded this summer.

Giants forced to face harsh reality with Luis Arraez

"While the Giants love having second baseman Luis Arraez, who's willing to sign an extension, the cold-hearted truth is that they need to clear infield spots for Casey Schmitt and Bryce Eldridge, leaving Arraez out of the picture," Nightengale writes. "They also already have six players earning more than $20 million this year."

The Giants, as much as they might want to keep Arraez in San Francisco for a long time, don't really have much of a pathway to do so.

He's hitting free agency after the 2026 season, and if they don't re-sign him, losing him over the offseason for nothing would be a massive missed opportunity.

But, beyond that aspect of things, the Giants don't really have the room for Arraez to stick around beyond 2026 on a long-term deal.

MORE: Phillies trade idea lands Jung Hoo Lee and Robbie Ray from Giants for 2 prospects

Casey Scmitt and Bryce Eldridge need to be everyday starters, and with Rafael Devers, Willy Adames, and Matt Chapman in play, there's no room for Arraez in the infield.

Not to mention that Arraez would likely receive a huge new contract after a breakout season defensively, paired with a strong season at the plate with a .332 batting average, an .834 OPS, and a 136 OPS+.

As much as the Giants and Arraez might want to stick together, the infield logjam, along with the team's limited spending power, makes a potential long-term deal for Arraez a lot less likely, and a trade of the second baseman a lot more possible.

Nightengale called this situation one where the Giants have to come to terms with the "cold-hearted truth" that Arraez can't really be in their long-term plans. It's a harsh reality for the Giants, but trading Arraez is in the best interest of the franchise this summer.